Blog

Cerrito Theater in El Cerrito: The Story Behind Its 20th Anniversary

On November 1, 2006, the curtain at 10070 San Pablo Avenue went up on "Casablanca." The movie house had been dark for more than four decades. On Monday, November 9, 2026, from 6 to 8 p.m., the El Cerrito Historical Society will gather at the theater to celebrate the reopening's 20th anniversary, which falls on November 1. The program covers how the theater was saved, restored and rebuilt, and includes a screening of filmmaker Rustin Thompson's new documentary about the people keeping old cinemas alive across the West.

That 2006 reopening was the first save, and it held for less than three years. The theater has needed saving three times. The rescue most likely to keep Rialto Cinemas Cerrito open for decades came in 2018, and it happened because Sacramento made the city sell the building.

Four Decades as a Furniture Warehouse

The Cerrito opened on Christmas Day, 1937, with "Thin Ice." Architect William B. David gave it an Art Deco interior with murals, etched glass and chandeliers. It stopped showing movies in the early 1960s. A 2006 San Francisco Chronicle account dates the closing to 1962. The Friends of the Cerrito Theater history says newspaper movie ads stopped in 1963 and that the building went to the Kiefer family in 1966. For decades after that it served as Kiefer's furniture storage.

That long stretch as a warehouse is the reason a restoration was possible at all. In 2001 the building came on the market for the first time in 40 years. Residents went inside and found that the Art Deco murals and mirrors had survived. The timeline moved quickly after that:

  1. February 2002. Friends of the Cerrito Theater forms.
  2. May 3, 2002. A Friends open house draws about 3,000 people.
  3. June 2002. The City and its Redevelopment Agency vote to buy the building.
  4. November 1, 2006. The theater reopens with "Casablanca."

The Chronicle put the project at $5.4 million. Most of that was loans, and the City fronted most of the renovation money. The work brought back the marquee, added a second screen and a café, and upgraded seismic safety and accessibility while conserving the original interior. Friends co-chair Ann Lehman and restoration advocate David Weinstein helped lead the community side. By the Friends' count, the group grew to more than 2,000 supporters and 425 donors. Today both auditoriums have an elevator and wheelchair seating, and the theater offers Rear Window Captioning and DVS Theatrical for deaf and blind patrons.

The Second Rescue Took Six Weeks

Speakeasy Theaters ran the restored Cerrito first. In June 2009 that operator announced it would close the theater, and it closed soon after. The City still owned the building and went looking for a new operator, and the Friends describe "an outpouring of community support" during the search. Rialto Cinemas started showing first-run, independent and art films on July 15, 2009.

Rialto came with a track record. As the East Bay Times reported in November 2025, director Ky J. Boyd opened his first arthouse, Rialto Cinemas Lakeside in Santa Rosa, in 2000. Rialto took over Berkeley's Elmwood Theater in 2007, added the Cerrito in 2009, and opened in Sebastopol in 2012. In a 2024 San Francisco Bay Times interview, Boyd called the Cerrito the group's full-kitchen location and its most commercial venue.

The 2009 handoff kept the screens lit. It left the bigger question open. The City still owned a historic building it had borrowed heavily to restore, and the operator was a tenant.

The Third Rescue Came From Sacramento

In 2012 California shut down local redevelopment agencies and told them to sell their assets. The Cerrito was one of those assets. In June 2018, Patch reported that the El Cerrito City Council had voted unanimously to sell the theater to Rialto Cinemas, its operator, for $790,000.

A forced sale could have put the murals at risk. The sale terms went the other way. According to Patch, the agreement includes:

  • A 99-year commitment to operate the building as a cinema or performance space
  • A 99-year commitment to preserve its historic elements
  • A City right to inspect the theater while any work is being done
  • A requirement that changes follow the U.S. Secretary of the Interior's standards for treating historic properties

Weinstein explained to Patch why the commitments are written into the deed:

"This is not just part of a shake-hands agreement -- it's part of the deed."

He also told Patch the Friends had worried about the murals, the marquee, the Art Deco glass and the original interior paint if another company ever bought the theater from Rialto. Because the obligations are attached to the deed, they bind whoever owns the building next. They do not depend on Rialto staying in business.

The Friends' own long-term goals had included placing the theater on the National Register of Historic Places. The group had also explored a historic preservation easement to protect the murals, lighting and glass. The 2018 deed terms cover much of the same ground. As of the East Bay Times profile in November 2025, Rialto owns the Cerrito building, having bought it from the city's now-defunct development agency. In the same story, Boyd credited careful programming as a large part of why the independent group has survived while competitors fell to skyrocketing rents and streaming. Owning the building means the Cerrito does not face the first of those pressures.

What's on the Screens Between Now and the Holidays

The Friends never disbanded after 2006. They stayed on as a watchdog group for the building and its historic features. They also present the Cerrito Classics series, and in September they said November's classic would give way to the anniversary event. As of mid-October, this is what the theater's listings show for the rest of the year:

Date Program Series
Wed., Oct. 14, 10 a.m. Così fan tutte Met Opera Live in HD
Wed., Oct. 21, 6:30 p.m. The Misanthrope, starring Sandra Oh National Theatre Live
Wed., Oct. 28, 10 a.m. Macbeth Met Opera Live in HD
Thu., Oct. 29, 6 p.m. Little Shop of Horrors Cerrito Classics
Mon., Nov. 2, 6:30 p.m. The Misanthrope National Theatre Live
Sun., Nov. 8, 10:30 a.m. Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit Family screening
Mon., Nov. 9, 6–8 p.m. 20th-anniversary celebration and documentary El Cerrito Historical Society
Thu., Nov. 12, 1 p.m. and Mon., Nov. 16, 6:30 p.m. Fallen Angels Filmed Broadway production
Sun., Dec. 6, 10 a.m. A Christmas Story Free family matinee
Thu., Dec. 10, 6 p.m. Scrooged Cerrito Classics
Sun., Dec. 13, 10 a.m. The Polar Express Free family matinee
Wed., Dec. 16, 9 a.m. Samson et Dalila Met Opera Live in HD
Sat., Dec. 19, 10 a.m. The Magic Flute Met holiday encore
Sun., Dec. 20, 10 a.m. Elf Free family matinee

The opera dates are the Cerrito's own. The Met's official live transmissions of Così fan tutte, Macbeth and Samson et Dalila fall on October 3, October 17 and December 5. Free family matinee tickets are handed out at the box office two days before each show, starting December 4, 11 and 18.

Regular film admission is $15.25 for adults at the box office and $16.75 online, where a $1.50 fee is included. National Theatre Live costs $29 for adults at the box office. The box office opens 15 minutes before the day's first show. The kitchen serves pizza, burgers, shareables and salads, with eight beers on tap and wine by the glass or bottle. According to the East Bay Times, meals come out to your seat.

A Second Walk Through Local History, Six Days Later

The Historical Society has one more event on its fall calendar. On Sunday, November 15, from 10 to 11 a.m., it leads a free two-mile walk along the Ohlone Greenway. The group meets on Fairmount Avenue across from El Cerrito Plaza BART and finishes at Del Norte BART. The Society spells the anniversary documentary "The Last Pictures Shows." Rustin Thompson's own page titles it The Last Picture Shows and describes a trip to 123 theaters in ten states over 10,825 miles. The film screens at the Cerrito on November 9.

If you own a home here and want to know how its records, its original features and its place in the neighborhood affect its value, Darrell Hoh and the Hoh Real Estate Group can walk you through it. Schedule a 15‑Minute Strategy Call.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Us

Our expansive network and white-glove service ensure a bespoke experience for both buyers and sellers.
Contact Us
Follow Us